Mesa Police arrest serial sexual assault suspect

Mesa, AZ – In the evening on August 29, 2021, the Mesa Police Department arrested and booked Carl L. Creamer (DOB: 7-27-1977) on multiple counts of sexual assault, aggravated assault, kidnapping, one count of attempted sexual assault and one count of sex abuse.

Mesa Police investigators began working this case on August 16, 2021, when the first victim came forward.  This victim reported being sexually assaulted at gunpoint.  Ten days after the initial victim came forward a second, independent victim, came forward and reported she was the victim of a violent attempted sexual assault where the suspect struck her on the head with a handgun before she was able to escape.

Investigators quickly linked the cases due to the similarities in the suspect description, violent tendencies of the suspect and the suspect vehicle described by both victims.  During a canvass of the area where the first sexual assault occurred surveillance video was obtained depicting a gold colored 2000’s model Ford F-150 pickup truck with several distinctive decals attached to its rear window.  The license plate number was not readable in the surveillance video.

Investigators tirelessly conducted follow-up on the information obtained from video surveillance and victim testimony but were unable to positively identify a suspect.  After exhausting all viable leads a crime bulletin was released to the public that received local media coverage.  From the release of the bulletin tips were called into the Mesa Police Department.  Through a tip, a 2002 Ford F-150 pickup truck, with decals in the rear window, matching the description given by victims was identified.  This vehicle was registered to Carl Creamer.

Through a photo line-up Creamer was positively identified as the suspect by one of the victims.  Creamer’s truck was later located by investigators in the 4800 block of S. 23^rd Ave. in Phoenix.  When located the decals had been removed from the rear window of the truck and the truck’s tailgate was in the down position obscuring the license plate.  While conducting surveillance on the residence where the truck was located Creamer was seen leaving in a different vehicle.  A traffic stop was conducted by detectives and Creamer was taken into custody without incident.

Creamer declined to speak with investigators and was booked into jail on the above-mentioned charges.  During the service of search warrants on Creamer’s apartment in Mesa, the residence in Phoenix, his truck and the vehicle he was stopped in several items of evidence were collected to include a tan colored handgun matching the description of the weapon used in the crimes, a specific t-shirt described by victims worn by Creamer during the commission of the crimes, and the decals that were removed from the truck.  Other evidence was video of the truck being at both locations where the crimes were committed and the fact both victims, who did not know each other, told matching stories during interviews with detectives. 

This investigation and arrest of this violent serial sexual assault suspect is a prime example of the Mesa Police Department’s relentless crime fighting model.  The Mesa Police Department members that were involved in this investigation include the Mesa Family Advocacy Center/Special Victims Unit, Major Crimes Unit, Violent Offender Unit, Gang Unit, Central Patrol District Bike Team, Criminal Investigations, Crime Scene Specialists and the Mesa Police Crime Lab staff.  They all tirelessly worked this investigation until this suspect was identified, located and arrested.  But, let us also recognize the crime fighting partners that assisted in the identification of this violent suspect.  The community members that provided the tips and the Mesa Police Department’s partners in the media that assisted in getting vital information out to their viewers and listeners.  This teamwork/partnership with the Mesa Police Department all assisted in identifying and locating Creamer, ultimately leading to his arrest.

Carl Creamer